top of page
Fig-Leaf-Fertility-V1-Colour-Black-Type.

Hyperfertility

4 days ago
4 min read

Ok, there's a terminology issue that's a great big elephant in the fertility charting room. Different people in the fertility charting space have their own ideas about what "hyperfertility" means.


It's important to know that we do already have established definitions for hyperfertility. Here's what exists in a formal sense:


1. Hyperfertility is a somewhat theoretical condition in medical literature. The theory is that an overstimulated reproductive system in women causes frequent pregnancies with frequent early miscarriages (often around the 6 week mark.) Medically, it's classified as recurrent pregnancy losses, not as a woman with a large family or close spacing. One idea for what might cause this unfortunate condition is that normally, the endometrial lining has a role in assessing an embryo's viability and rejecting those that are abnormal or unlikely to develop properly, meaning implantation cannot successfully occur. In hyperfertility, the idea is that this gatekeeping process fails. The lining allows virtually all embryos to implant. Because many of these embryos are genetically abnormal and destined to fail, miscarriage follows. 


This theorized condition includes some patterns: 

a) rapid conception

b) multiple early miscarriages / "chemical pregnancies"

c) textbook regular predictable menstrual cycles (the 28 day thing) with menarche often beginning at a young age, such as 9-10yo

d) a possible longer window of implantation allowing abnormal embryos to implant (the longer implantation takes, the likelier miscarriage is... see, for example, this study comparing miscarriage rates for implantation at 9 days compared to 12+ days.)


The reason this is considered a theory is that routine testing and karyotyping often come back normal, so if early losses aren't in fact due to other reasons (immune or clotting disorders, progesterone deficiency etc.) we don't yet have any firmly established cause and treatment. 


2. For a non-medical definition, hyperfertility can be used to describe women who have significantly more than the normal historical fertility rate of 3-8 children. So, the mother of St. Catherine of Siena could be considered hyperfertile because she bore 25 children. An example of this use of the term is found here.


In casual use in social media charting groups and discussions, I get the sense that more would be using the second definition than the first. I know that sometimes women suffering with the first sense of the word may visit fertility charting groups discussing hyperfertility, only to find people upset at finding themselves unintentionally pregnant and having multiple children to care for when they feel stretched far too thin, while the woman mourning repeated miscarriages longs for a living baby. These are very difficult, and very different, hardships.


But also in these casual groups, people tend to use the word to just mean that they get pregnant easily (without the recurrent early miscarriages that bedevil the hyperfertile) or that they have Irish twins/triplets or lots of kids close together in age, even if they're still well within the 3-8 kid range of the "normal historical fertility rate". Or even if they've simply conceived their first time trying (nearly 40% of couples using NFP to conceive will meet success in their first cycle!) None of these fit either of the formal definitions, and in many cases may simply reflect a normal healthy fertility. What about women who've had method failures? If we say most methods are roughly 99% effective, then 1 out of every 100 women can expect to have a method failure pregnancy over a year of charting. I'm an NFP instructor and in my early NFP experience I had a method failure with Creighton postpartum and a method failure with Marquette postpartum. I didn't have any method failures with BCC in my subsequent 2 postpartum charting experiences, so maybe that method just fit my body better than the others. But also, efficacy postpartum is generally considered to be a bit lower, so method failures are just statistically more likely then. (Eg. 98% with Marquette instead of the roughly 99% for regular cycle use.) So in that scenario, you have double the failures, at two out of every 100 women over a year, instead of just one.

So a method failure does not necessarily equal hyperfertility. Method failures are statistically normal experiences expected by the inherent imperfection of the methods (whether NFP or contraceptive.) I personally think we should be normalizing the incidences of method failures - even while acknowledging the significant impact they have - because we do expect to see them. Research is ongoing to make methods more secure. Someone who has had many method failures over multiple methods may have a level of fertility greater than the methods can account for, so I can certainly understand describing that colloquially as hyperfertility. So we've ended up with a pile of different (sometimes contradictory) ways people are using the term!


The takeaways? 1. Don't assume someone using the word "hyperfertility" means the same thing you would mean. Listen/watch for context, or check with them if needed. 2. Be kind; many people are living with great hardships. Sometimes their genuine struggle is in a context we would actually wish to have, but comparisons in this area don't help anybody.

 
 
 

Comments


© 2019-2026 Fig Leaf Fertility. All rights reserved. · Privacy Policy

bottom of page